Thursday, November 26, 2009

Commenting on the Commentaries


It’s been 3 weeks since i last blogged the reason being exams, fever, block and boredom and that seems to be a thing of past now. Now people will see me regularly in other blogs and my blog as well. No welcome back comments please Praying

russarnold_nehra   I’ve been watching Test cricket between India and Sri Lanka for the past few days on Neo Cricket. The cricket commentary, I should say is really below par. To be honest the Sri Lankan commentary team is horrible. The coverage isn’t all that interesting either. RK was very disappointing; over stressing every time he ends a sentence. It is irritating and fake. I will quote a few examples here of some shoddy commentary.


Russell Arnold on Thilan Samarweera
“He ees a very good player. He starts off very slow and scores slow. He ees not afraid to play his strokes”
Come Russell what are you saying, this is verbal diahorrea. Just because you are a Sri Laankan you need not speak highly of every Sri Laankan player. what you are saying is equivalent to saying Ladoo is very spicy.Raised Eyebrow


Another Instance of such a thing – Ranil Abenayake on Angelo Mathews:

Ravi Shastri asks “ tell me about Mathews where did he come from? A-cricket, First class cricket or Under 19 cricket”
“ He ees a very good player, can score a lot of runs and take a lot of Wick‘cut’s. He has come School Crick‘cut’, it ees very strong in Sri Laanka”

I dont knowCome on face it the guy has scored just a fifty that to against a Pakistan side which hasn’t played test cricket for a while and he didn’t pick a lot of wickuts as he claims.


Yuvraj is Batting on 73 and Dhoni is new to the crease look what our Russell is upto this time

“Sunny Last time Dravid declared when Tendul’car’ is short of a double ton, will Dhonee do that here to  you’veraaj(yuvraj)”
Sunny smiles sheepish and does not humiliate Russell and says “Pretty similar”  OMG he beats me in comparing incomparable.Big Grin


What happens when Sehwag and Gambhir are batting?


The first thing you need to know is that according to Sri Lankan commentators Sehwag becomes Shewag and Gambhir becomes Gaambeer.

The commentary gets the most clichéd when they are batting they repeat the same story over and over again. Our Indian commentators aren't  exceptions, they too have their fair share of torturing us. These are things they usually come up with especially Ravi Shastri.

“They play for the same state, franchise, club blah blah blah Chatterbox
“They are very goods mate off the field” – how many times will you say this Yawn
“Gambhir calms down when Sehwag goes haywire”
“they understand each other”
“Fantastic Four, super shot no one can stop Sehwag when he bats like this”
“ Gambhir is the second wall of India”
   What has happened to cricket commentary it used to be so much fun listening to them. Hallmark of a good commentator is to make a sucking game feel like a billion dollar.

“When you have nothing to say, just shut up. Try to complement the action in the middle and you need not describe the ball being rolled to the bowler“
                                                                                                       -Richie Benaud

    
I have some thoughts, how would it be if a Geometrist commentates?

“Sreesanth runs in straight line perpendicular to the popping crease and delivers the ball with seem which is 90 degrees and it pitches and deviates 78 degrees and Jayawardena holds his bat parallel to the ground and hits the ball which swerves like a curved line, bisects the field and  reaches the fence ”

    I switched Channels to watch Channel 9 commentary which included and commentary team of Tony Grieg, Richie Benaud, Michael Slater, Mark Nicholas, Bill Lawry and Ian Healy. Oh my goodness this commentary team rocks but does not get stoned like the one from Neo cricket. Commentary in India and sub continent as whole has a fair distance to travel to get where the above people have went. I pin my hopes on Sourav Ganguly.

There are commentators and then there Commentators:


Richie Benaud- The Grand old man of cricket commentary.
Mark Nicholas-  The man with the voice everyone would envy
Michael Slater – Former Aussie opener and a cheeky commentator
Ian Healy- Yet another Aussie with a flair for words and voice i would envy
Tony Grieg- One of the all time greats in this field and makes stupid matches seem interesting.
Damien Fleming- Newbie who packs a punch in his commentary
David Bumble Lloyd-  He is my favorite. I can watch a match between a bunch of nobodies if he is commentating.
Geoff Boycott-  The man with a Fascinating Yorkshire accent obsessed with technique.
Harsha Bhogle- The best Indian commentator if not the best in the world; a man who has a way with words and face behind ESPN star.
Ian Chappell- In your face guys who doesn’t fear anyone when it comes to expressing his opinion. He didn’t even spare the great Don Bradman.
Bill Lawry-  An awesome commentator with an even more awesome voice
Even the New Zealand commentary team seems to be doing pretty good

What do you think? Pour your thoughts in the comments section.

16 blesses 'n' curses:

Srini said...

agree point to point da. But come on, you are too much of a satirist it seems. :D. These Lankan blokes most of them come from fishing communities and the like with little or no schooling. Jayasuriya was a fisherman. Seen how he talks? Sanga is an exception, holds a PG in Law, and it tells.

As for the commentators you have listed I would agree with the description and the people save your Sunny saving Grace Gavaskar. His opinions are great, cheeky even, but I think his voice lets him down. That was - as I told you on chat the other day - Shastri is awesome indeed! :)

vEnKy said...

@ Srini

Ya i know but at least they should stay away from commentary. Cant imagine how Praveen kumar or munaf patel would commentate

vEnKy said...

@ thats is terribly true

Srini said...

simple! They wouldn't, not in English anyhow. :D. Plus whom do you expect Neo Sports to rope in? :P

Meow said...

Venks.. totally not my cuppa tea... forgive me dude :P

vEnKy said...

@ Meow

What abt you cuppa koozh hehehe

Neha said...

welcome back :P

i love watching cricket especially when its india i mute the commentary when i am watching alone its very peaceful that way...but when my bro is around he wants the commentary as well with high volume and says something this keeps the feel of the match wtf?

my favourite commentators will be siddhu, harsha bhogle and ian chappel they r osssum!!! others suck esp russel guy...

:)

HaRy!! said...

gambeeer!! enavo...wonder how they'll cal Venky :)! ya sidhu sadly is no more in cricket!

HaRy

Srini said...

@Venky

Despite his witticisms, I feel Sidhu was not that great as a commentator. There were moments of laughter and ones of daftness - nice entertainment although so if that is all you are looking for it was great. But I guess he did not quite have the same pedigree the other commentators you are speaking of had. That's my impression at least. :D

vEnKy said...

@ Neha

i agree with ur bro :D

vEnKy said...

@ Srini

EQ man Entertainment quotient thats what commentary is all about. Sidhhu has a lot of that

vEnKy said...

@ hary

no machi they will correctly pronounce venky but my full name Venkatadri no chance

Sojo Varughese said...

Somehow I have changed from an avid cricket fan to a staunch cricket loather. Nothing about Cricket excites me these days! Is that an illness? :)

vEnKy said...

Actually O made the other transfer from loathing to loving in 2003. You did not like this post :(

pawan said...

Venky,
After reading your facebook wall updates about Russell Arnold's commentary I was in splits. I didn't quite observe that in the first test match but from the second one onwards I started enjoying the fun. Ididn't expect a full fledged post out of it but man this post is a rocker. Surely you have a quite distinct funny bone.


Too good!
Cheers!

vEnKy said...

@Pawan

Thanks for the compliment, you have yours in place too. Hey check out my Blog-a-ton post buddy

Post a Comment